Sam Foxall's Avatar

Sam Foxall profile

4
Realo Foxtrot: Kitten Avatar
Realo Foxtrot: Kitten responded to Sam Foxall's comment in
3 Months ago
Federal court case will decide if Valve owns the rights to DotaFederal court case will decide if Valve owns the rights to Dota
Sam Foxall Avatar

The article's been amended to now make it clear that Valve own the Dota trademark. However, Breyer's summation of the case specifically mentions eul and Icefrog selling the copyrights to Valve.

Reply
Realo Foxtrot: Kitten Avatar

yeah, its annoyingly stupid misdirection which uCool are attempting. Most of this issue rely on uCool using the original (not all stars) code (the meaning of Open Source) which they are not. they are using Lilith's game.


The "Who Owns Dota" was taken to court before, as Riot "owned" the copyright of "Dota: All Stars" when they hired Guinsoo but sold the rights back to blizzard. Valve hired both Eul and Icefrog, and seem to have tried to get the copyright, but it was settled out of court, with Blizzard still owning it.


The Copyright strikes in question are in reference to the fact that they are using the likeness of Warcraft and Dota 2 models in Chibi form.

uCool's arguement 1. Dota is Open Source

Every Moba is inspired by the same code, doesn't hold up.

Arguement 2. Eul gave up the rights to "Dota"

Fine, but Valve then claimed them legally.


The fact that this has even had to go to court is just delying tactics by uCool so they can shift as much as they can before they invariably have to take it down


Speaking of which, uCool have 2 holding addresses in California and Boston with no actual idea of where they are based

sign in to comment
Sam Foxall Avatar
Sam Foxall commented on
5 Months ago
The Installation 01 team discuss multiplayer, Spartan customisation and more in this Q&AThe Installation 01 team discuss multiplayer, Spartan customisation and more in this Q&A
Sam Foxall Avatar
Thanks for the spot, we've just made the amendment.
sign in to comment
Sam Foxall Avatar
Sam Foxall responded to Aberrant Steel comment in
8 Months ago
Long awaited Homestuck adventure game, Hiveswap, finally comes to Steam GreenlightLong awaited Homestuck adventure game, Hiveswap, finally comes to Steam Greenlight
Aberrant Steel Avatar
Just wanted to say, it's not being developed by the Odd Gentleman after the bailed on the project to develop Kings Quest. It is being developed by an in house team called What Pumpkin Studios.
Sam Foxall Avatar

Whoops, our bad on that one. Thanks for letting us know and it's now corrected.

sign in to comment